Latest News

  • Tabletop Game Night 10.12.17 - Horizons

    Tonight we checked out the Kickstarter-funded game Horizons. It's got a bit of everything to it, taking concepts from deckbuilders to space exploration and colonization games, and resource managers . Essentially it's a "3X" game, so no extermination here! Five players vie for control and dominance among the stars, spreading energy and ore collectors as well as colonies throughout the galaxy. Who will earn the most victory points and take it all home..

    Read more ...  
  • ♫ Moving On Up to The East Side ♫

    Neutral Impact recently moved our guild house from Uldah to Shirogane and today we have finished the Castle glamour for our new home!  Thanks to Brac, Kiwi, Selef, and Bigwolf for helping out in the Company Workshop!

    Read more ...  
  • Tabletop Gameternoon 10.7.17 - Subterra

    Jroo joins us for his first game as part of Random Impact! Thankfully he brought with him some die-rolling luck. The same can't be sad for all. In Subterra we're all explorers trying to find the exit to this cave before the batteries on our flash lights run out! Will we reach the surface in time? Will we succumb to the fear of darkness, our bodies never to be found? Maybe a little bit of both? Watch on for the full play through on this episode.

    Read more ...  
  • Neo-Exdeath got Deathed

    On 9-27-17 Raid Team Clam finally defeated Exdeath and saved the Crystal president from the shattering terrorists or something.  Grats Witch on Genji Katana, Kiwi on Genji Chakrams, and Ashe on DRG body!  Looking forward to the new challenges patch 4.1 and beyond will offer us!

    Read more ...

What MMO should we plan for?

×

Poll: What MMOs should we plan for?

Crowfall
2 22.2%
Pantheon
4 44.4%
Life is Feudal
No votes 0%
Chronicles of Elyria
3 33.3%
Other (post below)
No votes 0%
Total number of voters: 9 ( wintertide, Seifer Arumashi, Ald, Jmillz024, Reli Turino ) See more
Only registered users can participate to this poll
More
1 year 3 months ago #11 by AIMonster
AIMonster replied the topic: What MMO should we plan for?

Seifer Arumashi wrote: Whichever is the most difficult of the 4 and consequently weeds out terrible players.


So none of those.
More
1 year 3 months ago #12 by Grey Jorildyn
Grey Jorildyn replied the topic: What MMO should we plan for?
As much as I disliked Pantheon's start due to all the legitimate drama that surrounded its early development, I believe it has the most likely chance to exemplify a "toughest MMO" category. We really have seen a lot of shit players come through the community over the past several years and it is disheartening to the max. We've also attracted some very, very good players, but they leave because of those other people. It would be nice to see a game that does some of the weeding for us.

What we need is someone who is willing to build it up. I was considering it myself, but those backer tier prices are just insane. I greatly dislike the way we "launch" or "fund" games these days. Early access is crap, and asking for $100+ before I even really know what I'm buying is just insane. That said, it's never been an impossible feat to find someone willing to lead. Just takes the right sort of person...
More
1 year 3 months ago #13 by AIMonster
AIMonster replied the topic: What MMO should we plan for?

Grey Jorildyn wrote: As much as I disliked Pantheon's start due to all the legitimate drama that surrounded its early development, I believe it has the most likely chance to exemplify a "toughest MMO" category. We really have seen a lot of shit players come through the community over the past several years and it is disheartening to the max. We've also attracted some very, very good players, but they leave because of those other people. It would be nice to see a game that does some of the weeding for us.

What we need is someone who is willing to build it up. I was considering it myself, but those backer tier prices are just insane. I greatly dislike the way we "launch" or "fund" games these days. Early access is crap, and asking for $100+ before I even really know what I'm buying is just insane. That said, it's never been an impossible feat to find someone willing to lead. Just takes the right sort of person...


Exactly how were old school MMOs tough besides the time investment required? Sure, they were penalizing enough, but a six year old could learn combat in an old school MMO since it's literally just pressing the same 2 or 3 buttons over and over again till something dies, pressing sit (in the case of EQ), waiting for a bar to fill, rinse repeat. Let's not even discuss the melee classes in EQ. I've seen old school MMO players completely fail at even playing these old school MMOs correctly.

The notion that we'll get "good" players by picking a MMO with old school mechanics is absurd. We'll get people completely incapable of playing a modern video game on part of the skill spectrum and we'll get people who are completely fanatical assholes who only play those types of games with no job or social skills on the social end. I'm not sure what you are defining good as.

None of these games do any sort of weeding, have you glanced at their forums by any chance? I've seen a lot of Pantheon's and Crowfall's. I'm not happy with the choices we have, but really we could make any of these games work, but I think people need to dispel that notion that this type of game is going to attract "good" players.

So that's why I think Pantheon and Crowfall are the best options. I don't really know anyone looking forward to Life is Feudal (they may be out there, who knows). Chronicles of Elyria wouldn't be a bad choice, but I just don't see that talked about as much as Pantheon and Crowfall these days. As for some others Ald mentioned:

Saga of Lucimia - Never heard of it. Looks like Everquest, as in almost straight up rips off Everquest. Features sound better than Pantheon IMO. Has this been generating any buzz?
Camelot Unchained - Definitely a good pick, I'd say this should be an option on the survey over Life is Feudal.
More
1 year 3 months ago #14 by Grey Jorildyn
Grey Jorildyn replied the topic: What MMO should we plan for?
I wrote a whole bunch of stuff that I didn't bother to put in this post in the end because I knew how you'd respond to all of it anyway.

In short a "good" player is someone who comes prepared, and when a game forces preparation to a high degree and isn't in the business of nerfing shit immediately to facilitate a wider array of audiences, it has a better chance to thus attract "good" players.

The survey has an "other" option. Camelot Unchained looks okay. Art styles effect my personal decision-making a lot about whether to play a game. However if the interest is there, we go for it regardless of what I think.
More
1 year 3 months ago #15 by Ald
Ald replied the topic: What MMO should we plan for?
I do believe the good players today are much better than good players in old school MMO's. Despite what some may think, large scale group content is much more difficult today than back then based on mechanics alone. However, the normal day to day non-raid content is abysmal in comparison in my opinion as are the average players. The ability to just show up without preparation or knowledge and still clear content on day of release is unacceptable to me.

Every new MMO going the action combat route with no form of trinity or class interdependence are some more reasons i like these possible future MMO's. My preference for tab-target with an expanded trinity including actual support classes points me right towards these MMO's. Call me old fashioned but it's what i prefer and i won't apologize for it. The player base in these games will be small but i believe the genre was better that way.

Login

Event Calendar

Sun Oct 22 @12:00AM
IGC Event - IGC's Birthday!
Mon Oct 23 @ 7:00PM - 10:00PM
Critical Impact - SW: EotE - Mask of the Pirate Queen
Tue Oct 24 @12:00AM
Nite Shift - Destiny 2 Launch
Mon Oct 30 @ 7:00PM - 10:00PM
Critical Impact - SW: EotE - Mask of the Pirate Queen

Servers